• Rescuing the Fourteenth Amendment Privileges or Immunities Clause: How “Attrition of Parliamentary Processes” Begat Accidental Ambiguity; How Ambiguity Begat SlaughterHouse

    Author(s):
    HC Admin (see profile) , Michael A. Lawrence
    Date:
    2009
    Group(s):
    MSU Law Faculty Repository
    Subject(s):
    Constitutional law, Law
    Item Type:
    Article
    Tag(s):
    Fourteenth, Amendment, privileges, immunities, Wm. & Mary Bill Rts. J., FacPubs, Other law
    Permanent URL:
    http://dx.doi.org/10.17613/fapw-bx76
    Abstract:
    This essay addresses a topic of great academic and practical interest currently facing the Supreme Court: whether the Privileges or Immunities Clause, which has lain dormant since the Court’s erroneous 1873 SlaughterHouse Cases decision, should be resurrected in order to apply the Second Amendment to the States. The essay makes the unique argument that the textual basis for the SlaughterHouse Court’s holding regarding the clause - i.e., the lack of parallel textual construction in the Fourteenth Amendment Section One’s first two sentences regarding citizenship - was in fact the wholly unintentional product of what we might call “attrition of parliamentary processes.” This analysis is not new to the Supreme Court. Borrowed from an oral argument made before the U.S. Supreme Court in 1882 by Roscoe Conkling (a member in 1866 of the Joint Committee on Reconstruction), the analysis played a vital role in leading the Court to its 1898 conclusion that the word “person” in Section One of the Fourteenth Amendment should be read to include artificial persons, including corporations - an interpretation substantially broader than that given previously by the SlaughterHouse majority. Just as the Court in the last decades of the nineteenth century corrected the Court’s too-narrow interpretation of Section One “personhood,” so it should now - finally - begin to correct its earlier misreading of the distinction in Section One between U.S. and state citizenship in order to restore the privileges or immunities clause to its full intended effect of applying the Bill of Rights (and more) to the States.
    Metadata:
    Published as:
    Journal article    
    Status:
    Published
    Last Updated:
    3 years ago
    License:
    Attribution-NonCommercial

    Downloads

    Item Name: pdf facpubs50fulltext.pdf
      Download View in browser
    Activity: Downloads: 7