• “Les meilleures Causes embarassent les Juges, si elles manquent de bonnes preuves": Père Norbert’s Militant Historiography on the Malabar Rites Controversy

    Paolo Aranha (see profile)
    Asia Lusitana, History, Religious Studies, World Christianity
    Asia, History, French literature, Historiography, History, Modern, Religion
    Item Type:
    Book chapter
    Capuchins, Church history, Missionary history, Malabar Rites Controversy, Anti-Jesuitism, Asian history, Modern history
    Permanent URL:
    Norbert Bar-Le-Duc (1697- 1769), also known as Abbé Jacques Platel, Pierre Parisot, Pierre Curel, traversed identities and continents, making a career out of controversy, becoming knowns as “le fameux Père Norbert”. He worked in South India as a missionary in 1736-1739 and thereafter played a pivotal role in the Malabar Rites controversy. Back to Europe, Norbert developed a literary offensive against the Jesuits, using historical memoires that accompanied Benedict XIV's ban of the Malabar Rites (1744), while being condemned by the Holy Office in 1745 and 1751. Norbert's life took an adventurous turn, the condemnation leading him to seek refuge in Holland and England where, ever the eclectic, he also established a tapestry factory. He later moved to Portugal as the protegé of the Marquis of Pombal. A major author against the Jesuits, he engaged with Jansenism, freemason networks, English early industrial entrepreneurship and Pombalism, changing his identity to assert himself in opposition to the Society of Jesus. This chapter considers the peculiar form of historiography that he developed in order to carry out his anti-Jesuit polemic. His own polemical “history of the present” was based on the use and abuse of the archives of Propaganda Fide in order to wage a successful war against the Society of Jesus. His works were often written in a careless and repetitive style but were always supported by a rich, if not pletoric, set of documentary evidence. He was a historian with the mind of a lawyer: he knew that “the best causes embarass the Judges if they are deprived of good evidence”.
    This chapter is the revision of a paper presented at the conference "Historia als Kultur. Geschichtsschreibung und Geschichtsforschung um 1700 zwischen Gelehrsamkeit, Politik und Konfession“, held at the University of Vienna on 23-25 September 2010. Here is the full programme of the conference: http://www.univie.ac.at/monastische_aufklaerung/cms/upload/Historia_als_Kultur_Tagungsprogramm.pdf
    Published as:
    Book chapter    
    Last Updated:
    7 years ago
    All Rights Reserved
    Share this:


    Item Name: pdf aranha-meilleures-causes.pdf
      Download View in browser
    Activity: Downloads: 386